No, ‘important’ genes are not shielded from mutation, a large new study finds

A recurring idea in biology, proposed in 1972 and revived in a 2022 plant study, holds that the genes an organism depends on most mutate less often, as if protected. That would challenge a core premise of evolution: mutations arise at random with respect to their usefulness. University of Bath biologists Laurence Hurst and Sofia Radrizzani tested the claim in PLOS Biology, using about 3,600 spontaneous mutations in E. coli and 4,600 in baker's yeast, ScienceAlert reports.
Essential genes mutated no less often than others. Only structural factors mattered, such as late DNA copying in yeast. The researchers suspect earlier results reflect selection removing harmful mutations, not fewer mutations arising. For freethinkers it is a neat case of a tempting claim failing a cleaner test.
Source: ScienceAlert (2026-11-16)
https://www.sciencealert.com/genes-arent-protected-from-random-mutations-just-because-theyre-important-major-study-finds
Summarised by the FTI newsdesk.