Why people who break the law for a cause fear punishment less

A study in PNAS from UC San Diego, described in Dutch by Scientias.nl, looks at what the authors call a Robin Hood effect. In a US federal database of more than 30,000 offenders, crimes committed for moral reasons were linked to higher re-arrest rates than crimes for money, though that is a correlation only. In experiments, 422 people imagined blocking traffic either for a cause or for pay, and the moral group cared less about the consequences.
In a money game, players accepted a fine to redistribute cash when unfairness looked deliberate. The researchers conclude that harsher punishment works poorly when people act from a sense of justice, and point to restorative approaches. For freethinkers, it raises a question: when does moral certainty turn dangerous?
Source: Daniel van Veelen, Scientias.nl (Dutch) (2026-11-18)
https://scientias.nl/het-robin-hood-effect-wie-meent-het-goede-te-doen-is-sneller-bereid-daar-een-straf-voor-te-riskeren/
Summarised by the FTI newsdesk.